Skip to content

Stars, Sieves and Stories

Physiognomy

Physiognomy was the art of interpreting people’s character and life prospects by looking at the features of the body, drawing on the theory that God’s providential plan was writ in every element of the natural world. Facial features, moles and lines on the body were all potentially instructive. Guides to practising physiognomy were published in cheap pamphlets, and it might be practised by cunning-folk and travelling ‘gypsy’ fortune-tellers.

Physiognomy drew on the long-standing notion that the outer form of the body expressed the nature of the soul. Early modern society commonly framed deformities or disabilities as divine punishments, while beauty was associated with virtue. References to physiognomy in literary works and cheap pamphlets were often light-hearted, but ascribing meaning to the idiosyncrasies of bodies and faces nonetheless threatened to entrench social division.

In the nineteenth century, European scientists theorised physiognomy more extensively, and it became highly racially charged. Like phrenology (the practice of examining the shape of the skull), physiognomy was co-opted to explain the supposed superiority of Caucasians. In the early modern period physiognomy was usually not as overtly racist, but treatises on the subject often reinforced European beauty standards, favouring ‘delicate’ features such as thin lips.

face4
face5

Images from a discussion of physiognomy in a 1698 pamphlet on fortune-telling.1The True Fortune Teller (London, 1698 [1686]), pp. 71 and 60, Wellcome Collection.

The whole body could be interpreted by practitioners of physiognomy, but the face was usually the focal point. The guides below, from pamphlets published in London in 1686 and 1700, use moles, lines and facial features to divine character and fortunes. See if you can read your own!

Moles2Image and closing quotation below are from The True Fortune-teller (London, 1698 [1686]), p. 74, Wellcome Collection. Text on the interactive image is from The High Dutch Fortune Teller (London 1700), pp. 21-3.

moles

Facial features3Image from The True Fortune-Teller (London, 1698 [1686]), p. 138, Wellcome Collection; text on interactive image from the same work, pp.63-73; image from the same,  closing quotation from the same work, p. 61.

face6

Moles are held by the learned to be certain marks imprinted as it were by providence, characters whereby mankind is enabled to read himself, and know in many cases what shall befall him…

Physiognomy is a science that has been of high esteem by emperors, kings and princes, who studied it with care and diligence, as desirous of nothing more than by this art, to read men, and by the external parts, know and discover the inmost secrets of their hearts…

Defence of physiognomy published in 1579 by the English writer Thomas Hill.4Thomas Hill, The Contemplation of Mankinde (London, 1571), the Epistle.

…if a man diligently behold, not only the sundry and variable forms and shapes of living creatures, but also the form and fashion of man himself, [he] shall well perceive such marvellous differences of countenances, such diverse lineaments of the body, and they all greatly differing one from another, so that man may not, nor ought to attribute it to hap, casualty, or fortune, but only to the great providence and will of Almighty God, which extends itself unto the numbering of the hairs of man’s head…

Astrological physiognomy, from another fortune-telling pamphlet.5Aristotle’s Legacy, or his Golden Cabinet of Secrets, trans Dr Solman (London, [1690?]), pp. 52-3, Google Books.